Sugar reduction claims: how do they work?

Dark sugarfree chocolate tablet with praline filling

Sugar reduction claims: how do they work?

Finding it hard to navigate across the various sugar reduction claims and strategies? We summarized the key things you need to know so you can pick the best strategy for your chocolate products.

What are the different sugar reduction strategies in chocolate?

Sugar reduced mini donuts

Sugar reduced mini donuts

1 - Reduce sugar without claim

The first question to ask yourself is whether you want to make a sugar reduction claim on pack or not. If that’s not the case, you have 2 options:

  • Gradually reduce sugar 
  • Reduce sugar up to 30% (30% is the threshold at which a claim can be made) 

In both cases, Barry Callebaut experts can support you by helping you reformulating your chocolate recipe.

2 - Sugar reduction claim

In order to make the claim “Sugars reduced”, added sugars in your overall product need to be reduced by at least 30%.

Be careful: the benchmark not your current product. The benchmark is against a range of reference of products on the market that are not reduced in sugars.

At Barry Callebaut, we selected the most suitable fibers for a balanced taste profile, good workability and digestive tolerance.

Rice wafers coated in no added sugar chocolate

Rice wafers coated in no added sugar chocolate

3 - No added sugar

Removing sugars on the ingredient list? Not adding any sugar to the chocolate recipe? That’s the “without added sugar” option

  • If polyols (such as maltitol, erythritol, …) are used in your product recipe, there is a risk of laxative warning on pack. In order to avoid it, the overall polyol content of your product should stay below 10%. 
  • If fibers are used (such as chicory root fiber) or polyols are below 10% in the recipe, there is no laxative warning.

4 - Sugar-free

The “sugar-free” claim means completely removing sugars from the nutritional table: no more than 0,5% sugars can be in the final product. This type of chocolate is particularly suitable for diabetics but come with a laxative warning.

We use a combination of maltitol and sweeteners such as stevia to replace sugars, and we remove lactose from our milk powder, so no sugars are left in the nutritional.

Keep reading about sugar reduction

Sugar reduced chocolate

Milk chocolate without added sugar (Mix)

Milk chocolate without added sugar. The sugars in this chocolate are replaced with maltitol, dietary fiber blend and the natural sweetener steviol glycosides, also known as stevia, to keep the sweet taste of chocolate. 

  • range
  • Fluidity
    3
  • Cocoa intensity
    1
  • Min. % Dry cocoa solids
    43.7%
Sugar free dark chocolate

A real sugar-free chocolate with max 0.5% of sugar in a dark version. Based on maltitol as the sugar replacer to keep the sweet taste of chocolate. 

  • range
  • Fluidity
    3
  • Cocoa intensity
    2
  • Min. % Dry cocoa solids
    53.7%
Dark chocolate without added sugar low fatbloom risk

This dark chocolate without added sugar is good as well as tasty. It contains maltitol and a butter oil fraction to decrease the risk of blooming. 

  • range
  • Fluidity
    3
  • Cocoa intensity
    2
  • Min. % Dry cocoa solids
    53.8%
All-round Dark chocolate with reduced fatbloom risk

Dark all-round chocolate with the perfect rheology to enrobe or mold the best creations. A perfectly balanced chocolate with mild cocoa intensity and additional butter oil to create a smooth texture and reduce fatbloom issues.

  • range
  • Fluidity
    3
  • Cocoa intensity
    3
  • Min. % Dry cocoa solids
    51.6%
Milk chocolate without added sugar for enrobing

The standard of our milk chocolate without added sugar. The sugar is replaced by the bulk sweetener maltitol to keep a great taste while remaining healthy. This chocolate is multi-applicable thanks to the high fat content. 

  • range
  • Fluidity
    3
  • Cocoa intensity
    1
  • Min. % Dry cocoa solids
    33.9%
White chocolate without added sugar (Malthitol & low fat)

White chocolate without added sugar. The sugar is replaced by the bulk sweetener maltitol. A white chocolate that is both good and tasty. 

  • range
  • Fluidity
    2
  • Min. % Dry cocoa solids
    27.5%
  • Min. % Dry milk solids
    22.7%
High cocoa Dark chocolate without added sugar

This dark chocolate without added sugar has a higher cocoa content and is made with maltitol as the bulk sweetener and sugar replacer. 

  • range
  • Fluidity
    4
  • Cocoa intensity
    3
  • Min. % Dry cocoa solids
    70.1%
Dark chocolate without added sugar (Mix)

Dark chocolate without added sugar. The sugars in this chocolate are replaced with maltitol dietary fiber blend and the natural sweetener steviol glycosides, also known as stevia, to keep the sweet taste of chocolate. 

  • range
  • Fluidity
    3
  • Cocoa intensity
    3
  • Min. % Dry cocoa solids
    70.3%